Let's Keep the Debate on Health Care
Washington, D.C.,
Nov 13, 2009 -
Last week, it was brought to my attention that a small number of individuals held disturbing posters depicting Holocaust victims at a press conference on the steps of the U.S. Capitol. Upon hearing the news, I immediately sent the following letter to Congressman Steve Israel (NY), the Jewish Community Relations Council, and members of the media to express my concern and disapproval of such grotesque imagery:
"Thank you for your recent letter regarding behavior exhibited by certain individuals during the course of the national debate on health reform. As a strong supporter of the Jewish community, I applaud you for the work you do each day, and certainly appreciate hearing your thoughts on this matter.
"While I believe strongly in the rights of expression and of free speech, it is critical to recognize that these rights are inherently accompanied by consequences, particularly when exercised irresponsibly. That being said, if an effective health reform proposal is to be reached, the debate surrounding health care must be rooted in fact and give all individuals the opportunity to present their arguments clearly, without resorting to personal attacks or emotional cheap shots.
"Sadly, some individuals have chosen to marginalize tragic events in human history, such as the Holocaust, by invoking imagery and labels which have no purpose in a policy debate about health care. These regrettable actions negatively shift the focus of the current discussion and do nothing but exacerbate an already heightened emotional element inherent to the public discourse on this issue. The American people deserve an open and honest debate to ensure the best possible solution to our health care problems and I agree that these unfortunate instances are wholly inappropriate. I know that we will continue to work together to maintain a civil and thoughtful discussion about the future of our nation’s health care system without condoning such distasteful tactics.
"Again, thank you for bringing these concerns to my attention. And, as always, please do not hesitate to keep me informed of your thoughts on these matters."
Throughout my tenure in Congress, I have made it a top priority to ensure our nation supports and defends our strong Jewish allies through my legislative agenda. To suggest anything otherwise would clearly represent a misguided and inappropriate attempt to unfairly characterize my long-standing, deep-rooted support for the Jewish community. Over the years, I have made numerous trips to Israel as an ongoing effort to foster the special relationship between the United States and Israel. These great people have extended the olive branch on many an occasion, even as they have been victims of violence and hatred, and I offer my continued support, respect, and friendship to them.
Click here to view a related letter I sent to the Star Tribune on June 16, 2009.
Read our blog at townhall
Take part in a tele-townhall
Sign up for mobile updates
Michele's help center
Email Michele
